If you’re a contractor in New York, you’ve likely experienced it: you land a job, you’re excited to get started, and then the contract hits your desk. Suddenly, you’re being asked for $1M/$2M Commercial General Liability limits, additional insured status, primary and non-contributory wording, waiver of subrogation, per project aggregate, no labor law exclusions, no action over exclusions, and a $5M umbrella.
It can feel overwhelming—and expensive.
But here’s the reality: these requirements aren’t random. They are carefully designed to protect the project owner, general contractor, and everyone upstream from the massive liability risks that exist in New York construction. Understanding why these requirements exist can help you not only comply—but position your business as a top-tier, professional contractor who wins more jobs.
⸻
Why These Requirements Exist
1. New York Is a High-Risk Legal Environment
New York’s labor laws—especially Scaffold Law—create strict liability for owners and general contractors. That means if a worker gets injured on a job site, upstream parties can be held liable even if they did nothing wrong.
Because of this, project owners and GCs push risk downstream—to you.
⸻
2. $1M / $2M CGL Limits Are the Baseline
A $1M per occurrence / $2M aggregate policy is considered the industry minimum because:
• Construction claims can escalate quickly
• Medical costs and legal fees are extremely high
• Multiple parties are often involved in lawsuits
Anything less simply doesn’t provide enough protection for a project of any meaningful size.
⸻
3. Additional Insured Status Transfers Risk
When you name the owner and GC as additional insureds, your policy is extended to protect them.
This means:
• If they get sued because of your work, your insurance responds first
• Their insurance is preserved, reducing their exposure
This is one of the most important risk transfer mechanisms in construction contracts.
⸻
4. Primary and Non-Contributory Wording
This requirement ensures that:
• Your policy pays first
• The upstream party’s policy does not have to contribute
Without this wording, insurers can argue over who pays, delaying claims and creating disputes. Owners want certainty—and this gives it to them.
⸻
5. Waiver of Subrogation Prevents Lawsuits
Normally, if your insurer pays a claim, they can sue another party to recover the money.
A waiver of subrogation stops that.
Why does this matter?
• It prevents your insurance company from going after the owner or GC
• It reduces legal conflicts between project participants
• It keeps projects and relationships intact
⸻
6. Per Project Aggregate Protects Limits
A per project aggregate ensures that your policy limits apply separately to each job.
Without it:
• One large claim on one project could exhaust your limits
• Leaving other projects exposed
Owners want to make sure your insurance is fully available for their job, not diluted by others.
⸻
7. No Labor Law or Action Over Exclusions
This is critical in New York.
• Labor Law exclusions remove coverage for claims under NY labor statutes
• Action over exclusions eliminate coverage when an injured employee sues a third party
If your policy has these exclusions, it can completely defeat the purpose of your insurance.
That’s why sophisticated clients demand policies that explicitly include these exposures.
⸻
8. $5 Million Umbrella Provides Serious Protection
A $5M umbrella sits on top of your primary policy and provides excess coverage.
Why so high?
• Severe injury claims can easily exceed $1M
• Lawsuits involving multiple parties can escalate quickly
• Owners want deep protection against catastrophic losses
In many NYC and Westchester projects, $5M is now standard—and sometimes just the starting point.
Real-World Claim Examples
Example 1: Scaffold Fall Injury
A worker falls from a scaffold and suffers severe injuries.
• The worker sues the property owner and general contractor
• Because of NY labor laws, they are held liable
How coverage responds:
• Your CGL policy covers the owner and GC as additional insureds
• Primary and non-contributory wording ensures your policy pays first
• The umbrella kicks in when damages exceed $1M
Result: A multi-million-dollar claim is handled by your insurance—not theirs.
⸻
Example 2: Property Damage from Negligent Work
Your crew improperly installs piping, causing a major water leak that damages multiple floors.
• The building owner files a claim
• Other tenants seek compensation
How coverage responds:
• Your $1M/$2M policy responds to the damage
• Per project aggregate ensures full limits are available
• Umbrella coverage applies if damages exceed primary limits
Result: The loss is covered without jeopardizing other projects.
⸻
Example 3: Employee Injury Leading to Third-Party Lawsuit
Your employee is injured and collects workers’ comp—but then sues the general contractor.
• The GC turns around and seeks coverage under your policy
How coverage responds:
• No action over exclusion means your policy does not deny the claim
• Additional insured coverage protects the GC
• Waiver of subrogation prevents your carrier from suing them
Result: A potentially devastating gap is avoided.
⸻
How BGES Group Helps Contractors Win
At BGES Group, we specialize in helping New York contractors not just meet these requirements—but use them to their advantage.
What We Offer:
1. Properly Structured Coverage
We ensure your policy includes:
• True additional insured endorsements
• Primary & non-contributory wording
• Waiver of subrogation
• Per project aggregates
• No labor law or action over exclusions
2. Access to Top Insurance Carriers
We work with carriers that understand New York construction risks and won’t cut corners on coverage.
3. Umbrella Strategies That Make Sense
We help structure umbrella policies that:
• Sit correctly over your primary
• Fill gaps
• Provide real protection—not just paper limits
4. Contract Review Support
We help you understand:
• What your contract is asking for
• Where the risks are
• How to negotiate better terms when possible
5. Cost Control Without Sacrificing Protection
Many contractors overpay—or worse, underinsure.
We help you:
• Balance cost and coverage
• Avoid expensive audit surprises
• Structure policies that grow with your business
⸻
The Bottom Line
These insurance requirements aren’t there to make your life difficult.
They exist because:
• New York is one of the most litigious construction environments in the country
• Claims are frequent—and often severe
• Owners and GCs need protection—and they expect you to provide it
The contractors who understand this—and align their coverage properly—are the ones who:
• Win better jobs
• Work with better clients
• Sleep better at night
⸻
Contact BGES Group
If you’re tired of guessing whether your coverage is right—or losing jobs because your insurance doesn’t meet requirements—we can help.
BGES Group – Gary Wallach
📞 914-806-5853
Reach out today and make sure your insurance isn’t just checking boxes—but actually protecting your business and helping you grow.