If you’re a general contractor operating in New York, you already know it’s one of the toughest, most litigious construction markets in the country. Between stringent labor laws, complex insurance requirements, and aggressive personal injury attorneys, one slip-up can turn a profitable project into a financial disaster.
In recent years, New York contractor insurance companies have significantly tightened their underwriting standards. One major development affecting general contractors is the widespread inclusion of what’s called a “Hard Hammer Clause” in liability policies. If you sub out work to independent contractors, understanding this clause and its implications is absolutely critical to protecting your business.
⸻
What is a Hard Hammer Clause?
A Hard Hammer Clause is a provision within a general liability insurance policy that requires the contractors you hire — your independent subcontractors — to carry specific insurance coverages, meet certain minimum limits, and name you, the general contractor, as an Additional Insured on their policies.
If your subcontractors fail to comply with these conditions and a claim arises, your insurance company can deny coverage for that claim. That leaves you holding the bag for legal defense costs, settlements, or judgments — potentially costing hundreds of thousands, even millions, out of pocket.
Worse, in labor law-related claims (New York Labor Law 240, 241, and 200), where general contractors and property owners can be held strictly liable for gravity-related injuries or unsafe worksite conditions, not having the right risk transfer agreements in place can be a death sentence for your business.
⸻
What Do Insurance Companies Require From Your Independent Contractors?
Under most current New York contractor insurance policies, here’s what you’ll typically need your subcontractors to provide:
• A Signed Insurance and Hold Harmless Agreement: This protects you by requiring the subcontractor to indemnify, defend, and hold you harmless against any claims arising out of their work.
• Commercial General Liability Insurance: Minimum limits are often $1,000,000 per occurrence / $2,000,000 aggregate, though some trades, like demolition, roofing, or high-rise construction, may require $2,000,000/$4,000,000 or higher.
• Additional Insured Status: Your subcontractor’s liability policy must list you, the general contractor, as an Additional Insured on both an Ongoing Operations (CG 20 10) and Completed Operations (CG 20 37) basis.
• Primary & Non-Contributory Wording: This ensures your subcontractor’s insurance responds first in the event of a claim, without seeking contribution from your policy.
• Waiver of Subrogation: Prevents your subcontractor’s insurance company from suing you to recover claim costs, even if you’re partially at fault.
• Labor Law Coverage: This is non-negotiable in New York. Without it, any injury claim involving a fall from a height, falling object, or unsafe working condition could bankrupt you if your subcontractor’s policy excludes coverage.
⸻
Why Compliance Matters
It might seem like overkill, but these risk transfer requirements exist because of how Labor Law 240/241 works in New York. Under these laws, injured workers (including your subcontractors’ employees) can sue the property owner and general contractor directly — regardless of who was at fault.
If you don’t have enforceable hold harmless agreements, proper insurance certificates, or subcontractor policies that comply with your insurance company’s requirements, you could face uncovered claims. Even a single uncovered labor law claim can lead to six or seven-figure settlements, potentially wiping out your company and personal assets.
⸻
What Can Go Wrong Without It?
Here’s a common scenario:
• You hire a subcontractor for framing work.
• They give you a certificate of insurance showing $1M/$2M limits.
• It’s missing Additional Insured, Primary/Non-Contributory, and Labor Law coverage.
• The subcontractor’s employee falls from scaffolding and sues.
• Your insurance company discovers the subcontractor’s policy doesn’t meet the required standards and invokes the Hard Hammer Clause.
• Claim denied. You’re now responsible for legal fees and any settlement or judgment.
If this happens, you could be on the hook for hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars. It’s not hypothetical — it happens every week in New York.
⸻
How BGES Group Can Help
At BGES Group, we specialize in protecting New York contractors from the pitfalls of labor law claims and insurance denials. For over 30 years, we’ve helped contractors navigate the minefield of coverage requirements, subcontractor compliance, and labor law exposure.
Here’s what we do for our clients:
✅ Review and draft custom insurance and hold harmless agreements tailored to your business.
✅ Verify subcontractor insurance certificates for compliance with your policy’s Hard Hammer Clause.
✅ Help you require the right coverage from your subs — including labor law coverage, primary & non-contributory wording, and waiver of subrogation.
✅ Access to a network of insurance carriers that understand New York construction risks.
✅ Secure affordable workers’ compensation and liability coverage with appropriate labor law protection.
✅ Provide ongoing risk management support to help you stay in compliance and avoid uncovered claims.
Bottom line: We keep you covered, so you can keep working.
⸻
Contact BGES Group Today
If you’re a general contractor in New York and you’re not 100% sure your subcontractors’ insurance meets the standards your liability policy requires — don’t wait for a claim to find out. Let BGES Group review your policies and subcontractor agreements before it’s too late.
📞 Contact: Gary Wallach
📱 Phone: 914-806-5853
📧 Email: bgesgroup@gmail.com
🌐 Website: http://www.bgesgroup.com
We service New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and can connect you with trusted associates nationwide.
⸻
Final Word
In today’s New York construction market, the Hard Hammer Clause is here to stay. Don’t take chances with your livelihood. Make sure your subcontractors carry the proper insurance and that your agreements are airtight. Better yet — partner with an insurance agency that lives and breathes this stuff, like BGES Group.
We’ll handle the paperwork, compliance, and risk management so you can focus on what you do best — building.