Businesses and Insurers Are Fighting Over Coverage for COVID-Caused Shutdowns
1. Have high value property located along the shore line or on islands like Fire Island, Block Island, Long Beach Island, etc? We have a property/liability/flood program that can give you the coverage needed. Call 914-806-5853 for help today!
2. Check out our new Construction News website which will tell you what’s going on in the construction industry throughout the country. Click here.
In courtrooms all over the country, battles are occurring between businesses who endured COVID-19-related shutdowns and insurance companies who believe they are not obligated to reimburse them for their losses.
According to the Covid Insurance Litigation Tracker from the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School, more than 1,800 lawsuits have been filed in state and federal courts, over a third of them by restaurants and bars. They seek to make insurers pay for business interruption losses suffered by organizations forced to shut down by government order during the pandemic.
So far, the courts are mostly siding with the insurance companies, but not in all cases.
State courts have partially or fully dismissed 85 of 117 cases. Federal courts have dismissed nearly 400 out of 414 suits against insurers. An August 31 decision by a federal appellate court in Atlanta is representative: The court dismissed a dental practice’s suit against its insurer, saying, “We do not see how the presence of (viral) particles would cause physical damage or loss to the property.”
However, judges’ opinions are not uniform on this question.
Business interruption coverage
Business interruption insurance reimburses an organization for lost income and necessary continuing expenses when it must cease operations after its location is damaged or destroyed. Such coverage is typically included in commercial property policies.
Affected businesses argue that their buildings were essentially lost to them because of an unpredictable event. State and local authorities restricted their operations due to COVID-19 or prohibited them from operating at all. The shutdowns cost them tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in income. Many may have to close permanently without insurance recoveries.
Insurers point to the words in their policies. Almost universally, the policies say that the carriers will pay for loss of business income resulting from “direct physical loss of or damage to covered property.”
The coronavirus, they argue, did not cause direct physical loss or damage. The buildings where the businesses operated are still there. The interior and exterior surfaces, furnishings and equipment all look the same.
To the insurers, property is damaged if it has been physically changed. The virus, they say, did not change the property, and in fact died out in a matter of hours if it was on the property at all.
In addition, many insurers added “virus exclusions” to their property insurance policies following the SARS epidemic of 2002 to 2004. These policy provisions state that the insurer will not pay for losses “caused by or resulting from any virus, bacterium or other microorganism that induces or is capable of inducing physical distress, illness or disease.”
In insurers’ opinions, this wording reinforces that they never intended to cover losses from a pandemic. Most courts have agreed with them.
But not all…
Some state courts have allowed cases to proceed, finding that the phrase “direct physical loss of or damage to covered property” is open to multiple reasonable interpretations. An Oklahoma judge faulted insurers for not clearly defining the phrase’s meaning.
More than 100 cases are on appeal. It will likely be some time before courts resolve the argument over whether a microscopic virus inside of a building causes damage.
If your business suffered any adverse effects from the pandemic, particularly if ordered to close, it’s important that you keep an eye on these cases, but you must have filed a claim with your insurer.
These cases will continue to play out in the courts.
BGES Group’s office, located in Larchmont, NY is a full service insurance agency offering, Property, Liability, Umbrella Liability, Business Auto, Bid & Performance Bonds, Inland Marine, Worker’s Compensation, New York State Disability, Group Health, Life insurance, Personal lines and Identity Theft.
Special Contractor Insurance Programs (NY, NJ, CT) – We we have 60+ insurance companies to market your general liability, umbrella liability, business auto, workers compensation, bid & performance bonds and group health coverages. We help contractors set up proper risk transfer. If you’re a contractor we offer extensive information about insurance markets, coverages, risk transfer, subcontractor screening, ways to lower your insurance costs.
BGES Group are Worker’s Compensation Specialists for the States of New York, New Jersey and Connecticut – Issues we address: 1) Lowering pricing – we have specialty programs that can save you up to 40%; 2) Finding a new company; 3) Replacing policies that are being cancelled or non renewed; 4) Audit disputes; 5) Company creating fictitious payroll at audit time; 6) Lowering high experience modifications factors; 7) Misclassification of payrolls; 8) Lowering or eliminating renewal deposits; 9) Getting coverage when you’ve been without for a few months; 10) Covering multiple states under one policy; 11) Eliminating 10% service or policy fees; 12) Timely issuance of certificates; 13) Always being able to get someone on the phone or by email when you need to.
If you would like to speak with us call Gary Wallach at 914-806-5853 or click here to email or click here to visit our website.
Company: BGES Group, 216A Larchmont Acres West, Larchmont, NY 10538
© – Copyright – 2021 – BGES Group